Reader analysis will be measured in batches of ~15 cases. Progress will be monitored by the CIP team and updated in the table below on a daily basis with the following indicators:
Completed - Reader has finished reading the case and submitted their AIM characterizations to the AIM data service
In Progress - Reader has been instructed to review this case, but has not yet completed it
Unassigned - Reader has not yet been asked to review this case
Readers must follow instructions for downloading the required data and installing the necessary software: VASARI Reader Instructions.
Round 3 Reader progress - Updated 12/18/12
(Note: the table can be sorted by clicking on column headers) Group Patient ID Scott Jim Brad Rivka Max Manal Prashant 1 TCGA-06-5412 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 1 TCGA-06-5413 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 1 TCGA-14-0789 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 1 TCGA-14-1041 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 1 TCGA-14-1397 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 1 TCGA-14-1456 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 1 TCGA-14-1794 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 1 TCGA-14-1829 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 1 TCGA-14-3477 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 2 TCGA-15-1154 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-15-1182 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-15-1232 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-15-1423 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-15-1601 Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Post-op 2 TCGA-15-2180 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-15-2237 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-15-2359 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-15-2379 Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Post-op 2 TCGA-15-2545 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-15-2552 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 3 TCGA-15-2591 Unassigned Post-op Post-op Unassigned Post-op Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-15-2681 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-15-2685 Unassigned Post-op Post-op Unassigned Post-op Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-15-2714 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-15-2737 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-15-2761 Unassigned Post-op Post-op Unassigned Post-op Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-15-2763 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-15-2777 Unassigned Post-op Post-op Unassigned Post-op Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-15-2825 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Post-op Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-15-2836 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-15-2954 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned
Round 2 Reader progress (updated 11/08/11 @ 2:15pm EST)
(Note: the table can be sorted by clicking on column headers) Group Patient ID Chad Scott Rivka Max Manal Prashant 1 TCGA-02-0003 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 1 TCGA-02-0006 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 1 TCGA-02-0009 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 1 TCGA-02-0011 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 1 TCGA-02-0027 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 1 TCGA-02-0033 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 1 TCGA-02-0034 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 1 TCGA-02-0037 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 1 TCGA-02-0046 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 1 TCGA-02-0047 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 1 TCGA-02-0048 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed 1 TCGA-02-0054 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed 2 TCGA-02-0059 Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed 2 TCGA-02-0060 Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed 2 TCGA-02-0064 Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed 2 TCGA-02-0068 Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed 2 TCGA-02-0069 Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed Completed 2 TCGA-02-0070 Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-02-0075 Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-02-0085 Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-02-0086 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 2 TCGA-02-0087 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 2 TCGA-02-0102 Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned 2 TCGA-02-0106 Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 2 TCGA-02-0116 Completed Unassigned Post-operative Unassigned Unassigned Completed 3 TCGA-06-0128 Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed 3 TCGA-06-0145 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned 3 TCGA-06-0160 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned 3 TCGA-06-0171 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned 3 TCGA-06-0174 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed 3 TCGA-06-0189 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned No T2/FLAIR No T2/FLAIR 3 TCGA-06-0190 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned Completed Completed 3 TCGA-06-0221 Unassigned No T2/FLAIR Unassigned No T2/FLAIR Unassigned No T2/FLAIR 3 TCGA-06-0238 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 3 TCGA-06-0878 Unassigned Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed 3 TCGA-06-0881 Post-operative Post-operative Unassigned Unassigned Post-operative Unassigned 3 TCGA-06-1084 Post-operative Post-operative Unassigned Unassigned Post-operative Unassigned 3 TCGA-06-1801 Post-operative Post-operative Unassigned Unassigned Post-operative Unassigned 3 TCGA-06-1802 Completed Post-operative Unassigned Unassigned Post-operative Unassigned 3 TCGA-06-5408 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 3 TCGA-06-5410 No T2/FLAIR (CT Only) No T2/FLAIR (CT Only) Unassigned Unassigned No T2/FLAIR (CT Only) Unassigned
Round 1 Reader progress (updated June 14 14:08 EDT)
(Note: the table can be sorted by clicking on column headers) Group Patient ID Dima Max Manal Prashant Chad Scott Arun 1 TCGA-06-0138 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 1 TCGA-06-0147 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 1 TCGA-06-0149 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 1 TCGA-06-0154 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 1 TCGA-06-0157 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 1 TCGA-06-0158 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 1 TCGA-06-0173 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 1 TCGA-06-0177 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 1 TCGA-06-0178 Post-op Post-op Post-op Post-op Post-op Post-op Post-op 1 TCGA-06-0187 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 1 TCGA-06-0241 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-06-0188 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-06-0214 Post-op Completed Unassigned Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-06-0237 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-06-0644 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-06-0645 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-08-0350 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-08-0351 Post-op Completed Unassigned Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-08-0352 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-08-0355 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-08-0356 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-08-0357 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 2 TCGA-08-0360 Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0385 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0389 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0510 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0512 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0516 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0518 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0520 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0521 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0522 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0524 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 3 TCGA-08-0529 Unassigned Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0122 Completed Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0127 Completed Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0129 Completed Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0130 Post-op Post-op Post-op Post-op Post-op Post-op Post-op 4 TCGA-06-0132 Completed Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0133 Completed Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0137 Completed Completed Post-op Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0139 Completed Completed Post-op Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0143 Completed Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0148 Completed Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0164 Completed Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 4 TCGA-06-0166 Completed Completed Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-06-0175 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-06-0176 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-06-0184 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-06-0185 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-06-0210 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-06-0646 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-06-0648 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-08-0244 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-08-0246 Unassigned No pre-contrast Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-08-0348 Unassigned No pre-contrast Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 5 TCGA-08-0354 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Completed Unassigned Unassigned 6 TCGA-06-0240 Unassigned Completed Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 6 TCGA-08-0349 Unassigned Completed No pre-contrast Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 6 TCGA-08-0353 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 6 TCGA-08-0358 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 6 TCGA-08-0359 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 6 TCGA-08-0380 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 6 TCGA-08-0390 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 6 TCGA-08-0392 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 6 TCGA-08-0509 Unassigned Completed No pre-contrast Unassigned Unassigned No pre-contrast Unassigned 6 TCGA-08-0511 Unassigned Completed No pre-contrast Unassigned Unassigned No pre-contrast Unassigned 6 TCGA-08-0514 Unassigned Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 7 TCGA-06-0118 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 7 TCGA-06-0119 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 7 TCGA-06-0121 Post-op Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Post-op Unassigned 7 TCGA-06-0123 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 7 TCGA-06-0125 Post-op Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Post-op Unassigned 7 TCGA-06-0134 Post-op Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 7 TCGA-06-0135 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 7 TCGA-06-0141 Post-op Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Post-op Unassigned 7 TCGA-06-0142 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned 7 TCGA-06-0144 Post-op Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Unassigned Post-op Unassigned 8 TCGA-06-0156 Post-op Post-op Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned In Progress 8 TCGA-06-0162 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned In Progress 8 TCGA-06-0165 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned In Progress 8 TCGA-06-0168 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned In Progress 8 TCGA-06-0179 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned In Progress 8 TCGA-06-0192 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned In Progress 8 TCGA-06-0213 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned In Progress 8 TCGA-06-0216 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned In Progress 8 TCGA-06-0649 Completed Completed Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned In Progress 8 TCGA-08-0381 No pre-contrast No pre-contrast Unassigned Unassigned Completed Unassigned In Progress
Batch 7 and 8 cases are not part of the Cancer Cell article but are in NBIA.
Notes:
- Dima disqualified TCGA-06-0130 and TCGA-06-178 as post-op
- Carlos email 5/20 indicates TCGA-06-0157 appears to be post-op but both Dima and Max had scored this.
- Scott email 5/24 indicates TCGA-08-0509 and TCGA-08-0511 do not have precontrast images. Adam suggested he would be in favor of throwing out such cases. Max has already read these two.
- Carlos email 5/25 indicates Cases 08-0244, 08-0246, 08-348, 08-0510 and 08-0516 are missing the T1 precontrast sequence.
- Justin found on 5/25 that Prashant scored TCGA-08-0529 twice. Sent email to get confirmation on which should be kept.
- Justin found on 5/25 that Manal scored TCGA-06-0166 twice. Sent email to get confirmation on which should be kept.
- Carlos email 5/25 indicates Manal has not read cases 06-0137 and 06-0139, they are also post-op.
- Dima email 5/25 indicates 06-0139 has two studies, the first after biopsy of left temporal lobe lesion (with some blood), and the second one after partial resection.
- Carlos email 5/28 indicates Max has not read batch #7 cases 06-0121, 06-0125, 06-0141 and 06-0144 because they are post-op
- Carlos email 5/28 indicates Max has not read batch #8 case 06-0156 because it is post-op nor case 08-0381 because there is no T1 precontrast
- Carlos email 5/28 indicates Max did not read cases 08-0246 and 08-348 because they are missing the T1 precontrast
- Dima email 5/27 indicates 06-0121: patient's scan done with fiducials, indicating plan for surgery, but there is already a left frontal craniotomy and suggestion of prior partial resection.
- Dima email 5/27 indicates 06-0125: patient has two scans, one labeled 12 July 1885 and the other one labeled 01 October 1887. The former is definitely immediate post-op. the latter shows enhancing tumor but there is evidence of previous left frontal and temporal craniotomy with suggestion of previous surgical changes in the left temporal lobe.
- Dima email 5/27 indicates 06-0134: left frontal craniotomy, surgical cavity and I believe there are gliadel wafers within the cavity. 06-0141: subtotal resection, recent surgery. 06-0144: right frontal craniotomy/ surgical cavity.